Discussion about this post

User's avatar
SILENT WITNESS's avatar

I can see myself skimming those whale-classification chapters and thinking, can we get back to the story already? Now I'm wondering whether that impatience is exactly what makes me miss Ishmael. His digressions may be telling me something the chase itself can't.

The Storygazer's avatar

Ever since I read Moby Dick I wondered why the book seemed to be less ‘epic voyage’ and more ‘whale textbook’ —at least compared to what I was expecting— but this is such an interesting point, that Ishmael’s scholarly bent *is* part of the epic voyage and the imprint it leaves on its sole survivor.

I often think of these scholarly chapters in terms of epic catalogue, one of the epic conventions whereby the storyteller establishes all of the extant knowledge of the narrative world they are building (examples being the list of Greek ships in the Iliad or of tree species in The Faerie Queene). It’s interesting to take that idea a step further in Moby Dick, that it’s not just the world of the novel but the world of Ishmael’s own psyche that these catalogue chapters are constructing. Thus these chapters are not just lists of information but manifestations of the fact that monomania can be contagious; though Ishmael does not have a determined vendetta against the white whale like Ahab does, Ahab has narrowed Ishmael’s world to this one topic through his own narrowing obsession.

Ready for more?