Athenaeum Book Club

Athenaeum Book Club

Why You Didn't Receive a Real Education

What the liberal arts were meant to do to the soul

Sean Berube's avatar
Athenaeum Book Club's avatar
Sean Berube and Athenaeum Book Club
May 03, 2026
∙ Paid

Real education is not what you think it is. In fact, most people have never received one.

Today we think of education as a litany of scattered disciplines that you study for careerism and social mobility:

Math is for engineers
Medicine is for doctors
Science is for biologists
Humanities are for poor people (it’s okay, I was an English major!)

The philosophy of modern education is to pick a discipline, stay in your lane, graduate, and begin your career. But this is not what education is at all — for most of history, education was meant to set you free.

A classical education taught you the seven liberal arts so that your soul could be liberated; freed from confusion and vice, ordered toward wisdom, and capable of living a meaningful life.

So what did that education actually look like? And how could it set you free?

Today, we’ll look to recapture the wisdom of a classical education, and learn how to give ourselves the true education that we never had…


Thank you for being part of our mission! If you’d like to support us and join the book club, please consider a paid subscription. You’ll get:

  • All live book discussions (biweekly) and recordings

  • Access to our incredible community of readers

  • The full library of articles, essays, and podcasts

We are currently reading Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment! The next discussion is on Tuesday, May 12, at noon ET — join us!


The 7 Liberal Arts

I’ve written in depth on the 7 liberal arts before, but I’ll briefly recap below.

The seven liberal arts were divided into two groups:

The Trivium — Grammar, Logic, Rhetoric
The Quadrivium — Arithmetic, Music, Geometry, Astronomy

Your education would begin with the Trivium:

  • Grammar teaches you how to read and speak

  • Logic teaches you how to think

  • Rhetoric teaches you how to express truth persuasively

Once you could think, speak, and articulate yourself clearly, you moved to the Quadrivium:

  • Arithmetic — number in itself

  • Geometry — number in space

  • Music — number in time

  • Astronomy — number in space and time

Why the emphasis on numbers? Because the Quadrivium is about training you to see order in reality itself. You learn that nature has an intelligent design, and that you are connected to it: you belong in the cosmos.

Despite this outline, however, it’s not yet obvious how this education is distinct from modern education. All of these disciplines, in some form, still exist today.

The difference with a true liberal arts education, however, is not simply what you study, but why you study it…

It’s All Connected

In a nutshell, a classical liberal arts education taught you how to find God. This doesn’t mean that you have to be strictly religious to receive a true education, but if you make God — the Ultimate, Transcendent Good — the end point of all education, it changes everything.

If your education is grounded in God, then the entirety of your education serves the same end: Goodness itself.

In other words, your education is no longer a set of scattered, independent disciplines. Instead, it becomes a deeply interconnected moral pursuit, teaching you to be attuned with truth, beauty, and goodness.

This interconnectedness is why the 7 liberal arts are presented as a wheel.

A true education is an encyclopedia, which literally means, “a circle of learning.”

Such an education assumes three key ideas:

  1. Knowledge is ordered toward unity

  2. The mind must be formed to perceive that unity

  3. Learning is a returning motion — you circle back to older ideas, seeing more deeply each time

So in totality, education is about learning to be in harmony with reality, and more than that, it’s about transforming the soul itself.

This might sound strange, but let’s turn to symbolism to explain. Have you noticed that the symbol of the 7 liberal arts looks strikingly similar to the rose windows of Gothic cathedrals?

That is no coincidence. Rose windows symbolize Heaven, suggesting that reality itself is patterned after them — and this same circular pattern is the symbol of classical education in the liberal arts.

The implication is that the liberal arts liberate your soul by forming you according to the pattern of heaven itself. Education, then, is preparation for eternity.

But how do you actually see this? How do you study in such a way that you’re not just accumulating knowledge, but learning to mirror the structure of Paradise itself?

Dante Alighieri answers this question in the Paradiso. He reveals the connection between the liberal arts, the rose, and the final destiny of the human soul:

He reveals how a life is brought into perfect alignment with the divine, and how you can reach it yourself…

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 Athenaeum Book Club · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture