Christianity in The Lord of the Rings

The Gospel inside the Ring

When people think about The Lord of the Rings, they don’t immediately think about Christianity. They think about wizards, elves, battles, and long journeys across wild landscapes. If you asked most fans what it’s about, they might say it’s about friendship, courage, or resisting evil. Tolkien himself insisted it wasn’t an allegory. He pushed back against the idea that the Ring was some crude stand-in for nuclear weapons or that Frodo was simply a Christ figure. But if you look closer, you realize something: the story is soaked in Christianity. Not in the sense that Gandalf is Jesus or Sauron is Satan in disguise, but in the way the whole moral universe of the book is built.

What Tolkien did was different from allegory. Allegory takes a Christian story and disguises it as something else, like Pilgrim’s Progress, where Christian is literally walking toward salvation. Tolkien hated that kind of one-to-one correspondence. Instead, he created a world where the air itself feels Christian. The choices characters face, the way victory is achieved, the meaning of suffering, the role of hope and despair… all of it reflects the worldview of someone steeped in Catholicism. He once admitted the book was “fundamentally religious and Catholic,” not because he inserted sermons into the plot, but because his imagination itself was shaped by the faith.

So, if you want to understand the deeper resonance of The Lord of the Rings, you have to see the Christianity beneath it. Let’s walk through that, piece by piece…

---

Don’t forget to join our FREE book club!

We started a digital book club to study the great texts of Western Civilization — from Dante to Dostoevsky — together. Inside, you’ll get:

• Live community book discussions (bi-weekly)

• New, deep-dive literature essays every week

• The entire archive of book reviews + our 100 great texts reading list

We’re back with our second Count of Monte Cristo discussion on September 30th at 12pm ET. Bring your thoughts, questions, and favorite passages!

Sign up below to attend — all paid members can join the live discussion up on stage…

Note: paid subscribers via Substack will automatically receive an access link for the live calls.

---

The Ring as Sin

The Ring is the most obvious starting point. It’s tempting to call it a metaphor for nuclear weapons, since Tolkien lived through World War II. But he denied that. Instead, it functions more like sin, or perhaps original sin. The Ring doesn’t just sit there as a tool to be used for good or evil. It corrupts whoever tries to use it. That’s exactly how sin works in Christian thought. You can’t harness it for good ends. It promises power, but it deforms you in the process.

Think about Gollum. He wasn’t born a monster. He was once a hobbit-like creature named Sméagol. But once he took the Ring, it consumed him. His body twisted, his mind broke, and his life shriveled into obsession. That’s what sin does. It takes a human being and makes them less human. Tolkien even shows that long possession of the Ring gives unnaturally long life, but it’s not real life. It’s a kind of spiritual decay stretched out across centuries.

The Ring also reveals the weakness in each character. Boromir, who wants to save his people, is tempted to use it. Galadriel, who is good, admits she would become terrible if she wielded it. Frodo himself almost fails at the last moment. The Ring is too much for anyone. No willpower is strong enough to master it. That’s a profoundly Christian idea: sin isn’t just about bad people doing bad things. It’s about everyone being vulnerable, no matter how noble they are.

Power and the Temptation to Dominate

The deeper problem with the Ring is the temptation to dominate. Christianity has always warned about the corruption of power, especially when it’s about control over others. “The rulers of the Gentiles lord it over them,” Jesus says, “but it shall not be so among you.” The Ring is literally the ability to lord it over others, to bend their wills.

And notice how even the good characters know they can’t trust themselves with it. Gandalf refuses it. Aragorn refuses it. Faramir refuses it. They’re not saying, “Oh, I don’t need power.” They’re saying, “If I take this, it will destroy me.” That’s humility. It’s also a very Christian recognition of human weakness. Greatness comes not from seizing power but from rejecting it.

This is why the hobbits matter. They are the least powerful creatures in Middle-earth. They don’t command armies or wield magic. But because they don’t crave domination, they are the ones entrusted with the burden. It’s almost like the Gospel idea that the meek will inherit the earth. God chooses the weak things of the world to shame the strong.

Providence Without Preaching

Another Christian theme is providence… the sense that there’s a guiding hand behind events, even when characters don’t see it. Tolkien never says “God” in Middle-earth. He doesn’t need to. Instead, you feel it in the way things unfold. Bilbo “by chance” finds the Ring, but Gandalf says it was meant to be. Frodo ends up with the task not because he wanted it, but because someone had to. Gollum, despite his treachery, ends up being essential to the Ring’s destruction.

That’s providence: the idea that even evil can be bent toward good by a higher power. Tolkien once wrote that history is a “long defeat” with occasional glimpses of final victory. That’s exactly how the story feels. The characters struggle, suffer losses, and barely survive, yet there’s always the sense that something larger is at work.

What’s striking is how subtle Tolkien makes it. There are no miracles in the crude sense. The eagles don’t swoop in every time someone’s in danger. Instead, events weave together in ways that only later make sense. That’s how Christians often see life itself: not a constant stream of miracles, but a hidden pattern where even mistakes and failures are used for good.

The Role of Suffering

In Christianity, suffering isn’t meaningless. It can purify, humble, or even redeem. Tolkien, who fought in the trenches of World War I, knew what suffering looked like. In The Lord of the Rings, the central characters don’t win by avoiding pain. They win by enduring it.

Frodo suffers constantly: stabbed by a Morgul blade, poisoned by Shelob, crushed by the Ring’s weight. Sam suffers too, carrying not just Frodo but also despair itself. Yet they keep going. Their victory doesn’t come from strength but from endurance. That mirrors the Christian idea that the cross, the ultimate symbol of suffering, is also the path to salvation.

And look at how Frodo finishes his journey. He doesn’t go home and live happily ever after. He’s too wounded. His body and soul are marked forever. That’s a deeply Christian picture: redemption costs something. Even the heroes don’t get out unscarred. Frodo can’t find peace in the Shire because he’s given his life for others. In the end, he sails away to the Undying Lands, which feel like a picture of heaven… not as an escape, but as a final healing.

Hope and Despair

One of the most important Christian virtues is hope. Not optimism, which is shallow, but hope in the face of despair. In Tolkien’s world, despair is the real enemy. Denethor, the steward of Gondor, gives in to it and chooses suicide. Saruman, once wise, falls into it and becomes bitter and cruel. Even Frodo comes close to despair.

But Sam never does. Sam represents hope in its simplest form. He doesn’t know if they’ll make it. He doesn’t know if there’s any chance at all. But he keeps walking, keeps carrying Frodo, keeps believing in a world worth saving. There’s a moment when he sees a star above Mordor’s clouds and realizes that no matter how dark it gets, there’s light beyond the reach of evil. That’s Christianity distilled into one image: hope rooted not in circumstances but in the belief that good will ultimately triumph.

The Hidden Christ Figures

Tolkien didn’t create one Christ figure; he spread Christ-like qualities across several characters. Frodo resembles Christ in bearing a burden for others. Gandalf resembles Christ in his death and resurrection after fighting the Balrog. Aragorn resembles Christ in his role as the hidden king who returns to heal and reign. None of them is Christ directly, but together they sketch out the image.

This is why Tolkien’s work feels so powerful without ever preaching. He doesn’t hit you over the head with theology. Instead, he shows you characters who embody sacrifice, humility, courage, and mercy. They live out Christian virtues in a world without churches, priests, or sacraments, but the pattern is unmistakable.

Mercy as a Weapon

One of the most striking Christian themes is mercy. Over and over, characters are told to show mercy, even when it seems foolish. Frodo spares Gollum’s life, even after he betrays them. Gandalf insists Gollum still has a role to play. At first, this looks naïve. Why not just kill him?

But in the end, it’s Gollum who destroys the Ring. Not Frodo, who fails at the last moment. Frodo couldn’t resist the temptation, but because he showed mercy earlier, Gollum was still there. Evil ended up destroying itself through his obsession. That’s how mercy works in Christianity. Forgiveness can look weak, but it has a power that vengeance never does. Tolkien makes mercy the decisive weapon in the story.

Evil as a Shadow

Evil in Tolkien’s world is never creative. It can only corrupt. Orcs are twisted versions of elves. Trolls are crude copies of ents. Mordor is a barren wasteland, stripped of life. That reflects the Christian idea that evil is not an equal force against good, but a parasite. It feeds on what is good and distorts it.

This is also why Sauron ultimately loses. His power is immense, but it’s based on domination and fear. He can’t imagine anyone trying to destroy the Ring instead of using it. That blindness is what undoes him. Evil always assumes everyone else thinks like it does, and that’s its weakness.

The Smallness of Heroes

Another Christian theme is humility. Great deeds are accomplished by small, humble characters. Hobbits are literally small, but they also represent ordinary life… gardens, meals, songs. They don’t seek glory, yet they end up carrying the heaviest burdens.

This ties back to Tolkien’s Catholic view of the ordinary. Grace works through small things: bread, wine, water. Holiness isn’t about flashy displays of power but about quiet faithfulness. Samwise Gamgee, the gardener, is the truest hero of the book. His loyalty, love, and perseverance matter more than strength or wisdom. That’s a profoundly Christian message: greatness is found in service, not domination.

The Shadow of Death

Death hovers over the whole story. Men are mortal; elves are immortal, yet even they fade. The Ring tempts people with the promise of avoiding death, but it always brings ruin. In Christianity, death is the enemy, but it’s also the doorway to eternal life. Trying to escape it leads to slavery. Accepting it, with faith, leads to freedom.

Look at Aragorn. When he finally dies, he embraces it willingly. He doesn’t cling to life but accepts it as a gift. That’s the Christian way of seeing death… not as something to fear endlessly, but as something to prepare for with hope.

Why It Resonates

So why does The Lord of the Rings resonate with so many people, even those who aren’t Christian? Because Tolkien didn’t preach. He built a story where Christian truth is woven into the fabric of the world. You don’t have to believe in Christ to feel the power of mercy, the nobility of sacrifice, or the hope that shines even in darkness. But if you do believe, you recognize the source.

It’s like hearing an echo. The story echoes the Gospel, not by copying it, but by living in its shape. That’s why people return to it again and again. It’s not just a fantasy adventure. It’s a reminder of truths deeper than Middle-earth itself.

Tolkien’s Quiet Evangelism

Tolkien once wrote that stories are a way to “sneak past the watchful dragons” of people’s resistance to religion. If you tell them doctrine, they argue. If you tell them a story, they listen. That’s what he achieved. The Lord of the Rings is a deeply Christian story, but you don’t feel like you’re being preached to. You just feel like you’ve encountered beauty, courage, and hope. And maybe that plants a seed.

In a way, Tolkien’s work is an answer to despair. He saw a world torn apart by war and industrial destruction, but he refused to believe evil would have the last word. His Catholic faith told him that victory might look like defeat, that the smallest act of mercy could change the world, and that even in the darkest places, light endures. That’s the Christianity of The Lord of the Rings.

Final Thought

If you strip Christianity out of The Lord of the Rings, the story collapses. The Ring becomes just a trinket. Frodo’s suffering becomes pointless. Mercy becomes stupidity. But when you see it as Tolkien intended, you realize it’s one of the most powerful works of Christian imagination ever written… not because it preaches, but because it breathes Christianity in every line.

That’s the genius of Tolkien. He didn’t set out to write a sermon. He set out to tell a story. But because he was a Christian to his bones, the story itself became Christian. And that’s why it still speaks to us… not just as a fantasy, but as a glimpse of the Gospel hidden in Middle-earth.